English Premier League

Bernardo Silva withdrawal explained as Portugal medical chief rejects Real Madrid favouritism claims

Published

on

Portugal’s decision to leave Bernardo Silva out of their Nations League match against Wales has prompted questions after the Real Madrid player returned to Madrid and appeared potentially capable of facing Celta Vigo on Saturday.

Jose Carlos Noronha, head of medical services at the Portuguese Football Federation, has defended the decision and explained why Silva left the national team camp after being ruled out of the match on 17 November 2026.

Silva experienced muscular discomfort during Portugal’s opening game against Denmark. The national team’s medical staff therefore decided not to risk selecting him against Wales, fearing that playing could worsen the problem.

The decision attracted criticism in Portugal after reports suggested Silva would have no difficulty featuring for Real Madrid against Celta Vigo on 21 November 2026. Concerns were also raised because he had left the camp without undergoing further, more detailed tests to establish the precise nature of the issue.

Noronha said: “To clarify briefly, muscular pain and spasms can develop into complete tears after a few days, even if ultrasound and magnetic resonance imaging scans produce negative results, which did not happen in this case.”

He added: “The player returned to Real Madrid, where imaging scans did not reveal any injury. I would like to point out that 50% of the complaints reported by patients do not appear on imaging scans.”

The Portuguese medical official said athletes who experience similar pain and then take part in a match or training session face a higher risk of suffering a muscle tear two or three days later, potentially resulting in a complete rupture.

Those concerns, Noronha explained, were why Silva was not subjected to a more detailed medical assessment before leaving the squad. The decision was taken to avoid placing his wellbeing at unnecessary risk.

“Magnetic resonance imaging, which is often used to diagnose these injuries, should also not be carried out during the first 24 to 36 hours unless the injury is extensive, because it can produce a false negative result,” Noronha said.

“We have dealt with cases of this kind before. Given the nature of the pain Bernardo felt, the procedure we followed was the correct one. We informed the national team manager that he was unable to play.”

Noronha also insisted that Silva being available for Real Madrid’s meeting with Celta Vigo would not contradict his exclusion from the Wales game.

“It is entirely normal for him to play on Saturday,” he said. “After the match, he asked to do some stretching exercises. In the end, he was injured on the 14th, so playing tomorrow would have been too early because this concerns a structural injury.

“Now, after 7 or 8 days have passed, it is normal for him to be able to play.”

Trending

Exit mobile version