English Premier League
Lionel Messi ‘should have been sent off’ in Inter Miami clash, says former referee Graham Scott
Lionel Messi should have been shown a red card after directing the ball into the face of Columbus Crew forward Gonzalo Tapia, according to former English referee and refereeing expert Graham Scott.
The incident occurred during the final minutes of the first half of Inter Miami’s meeting with Columbus Crew on 27 November 2026. Tapia had attempted to prevent Messi from taking a quick throw-in, prompting an angry reaction from the Argentine.
Messi then deliberately struck the ball towards Tapia’s face with force. The Columbus player fell to the ground after being hit, while referee Allen Chapman intervened to calm the situation.
Chapman showed both Messi and Tapia a yellow card rather than dismissing either player. The decision drew protests from Columbus Crew players, and footage showing the ball striking Tapia’s face quickly became the focus of discussion.
Scott told The Athletic: “If referee Chapman had shown a red card, it would have been the more accurate decision under the laws; the force used was excessive and there was no justification for it.”
Reposting The Athletic’s report on X, Scott added: “A deserved red card in my opinion; it was unjustified, deliberate and violent.”
He also acknowledged the difficulty of judging an unusual incident, saying: “I could easily have misread this incident too; referees often make mistakes when interpreting rare situations, as I cannot remember a similar incident throughout the 20 years I spent officiating professional matches.”
Inter Miami suffer heavy home defeat
The incident came during a disastrous night for Inter Miami, who were beaten 3-0 at home by Columbus Crew in the opening match of their first-round American league play-off series. The tie is being played as a best-of-three contest.
Columbus took the lead in the eighth minute when Gonzalo Tapia converted a penalty after Inter Miami goalkeeper Dane St. Clair brought him down inside the area.
Inter Miami’s task became more difficult in the 36th minute when Gonzalo Lujan was sent off after receiving a second yellow card, leaving the hosts with 10 players.
Taha Habroune doubled Columbus’s advantage in the 52nd minute before Tapia scored his second goal of the match, and his side’s third, six minutes later.
Messi had two dangerous chances in the first half but was denied by Columbus goalkeeper Patrick Schulte, who produced an impressive performance and kept a clean sheet.
The defeat has significant implications for Inter Miami, the American league champions. They must win away to Columbus in the second match on 27 November to force a third and decisive game. Another defeat would end their campaign.