English Premier League

VAR controversy as Al Ahli goal is ruled out against Al Nassr

Published

on

Al Ahli’s disallowed goal in their Saudi Pro League derby against Al Nassr has prompted a heated debate over whether referee Facundo Tello made the correct decision.

Al Nassr visited Al Ahli at Alinma Stadium in Jeddah on Friday for the rearranged fixture from the ninth round of the Saudi Pro League.

Al Ahli appeared to take the lead after 31 minutes when Merih Demiral headed into an empty net. Al Nassr goalkeeper Bento had come out of position, leaving the ball to fall to the Turkish defender in front of goal.

However, after initially awarding the goal, Argentine referee Tello reviewed the incident on the video assistant referee monitor and overturned his decision. He judged that Al Ahli midfielder Ziyad Al-Juhani had impeded Bento and prevented him from moving towards the ball.

The ruling angered Al Ahli head coach Marino Pusic, who confronted the referee and argued that the goal should have stood.

Former Egyptian referee Mohammed Kamal Risha supported Tello’s decision in comments to Saudi newspaper Al Riyadiyah.

“The referee’s decision to disallow Al Ahli’s goal was correct,” Risha said.

“Ziyad Al-Juhani obstructed Al Nassr goalkeeper Bento and prevented him from moving towards the ball.”

Former Saudi official Fahad Al-Mirdasi reached the opposite conclusion, saying there had been no foul on the goalkeeper and that the goal was valid.

“The decision to disallow Al Ahli’s goal in the 31st minute was incorrect,” Al-Mirdasi said in comments carried on the official account of the programme Nadina on MBC 1.

“Al Ahli player Ziyad Al-Juhani did not commit any offence against Al Nassr goalkeeper Bento Matheus. It was an incorrect intervention by the VAR official to ask the referee to review the incident, and the goal should have been awarded.”

The match produced another key VAR intervention after the break, this time in Al Ahli’s favour.

Demiral was involved again in the 67th minute when he went down inside the penalty area after receiving a cross. Al Nassr forward Abdullah Al-Hamdan had tried to reach the defender, who appealed for a penalty.

Tello initially ignored the Al Ahli players’ claims but then went to the monitor to review the challenge. He subsequently awarded a spot-kick to the hosts.

Ivan Toney took responsibility for the penalty and struck a powerful effort to Bento’s right. The Brazilian goalkeeper could not get to the ball, giving Al Ahli their second goal of the match in the 71st minute.

The two decisions involving Demiral have therefore become central to the refereeing debate surrounding the Jeddah classic, with Risha backing the decision to cancel the first goal while Al-Mirdasi maintained that Al Ahli should have been awarded it.

Trending

Exit mobile version