English Premier League
Gary Neville condemns Manchester United’s ‘shocking’ defending after early Liverpool collapse

Gary Neville has described Manchester United’s defending as the worst he has seen from a pair of centre-backs dealing with a long ball after mistakes by Matthijs de Ligt and Leny Yoro helped Liverpool take control of Mauricio Pochettino’s first match in charge.
Yoro was sent off after only eight minutes when he brought down Alexander Isak as the Liverpool forward ran through on goal. Manchester United were reduced to 10 players and soon found themselves two goals behind.
The trouble began when Ronald Araujo sent a long pass over the United defence. De Ligt misjudged the flight of the ball and allowed it to run through to Isak, who had a clear route towards goal.
Yoro attempted to recover but could not stop Isak legally. Referee Sam Barrott showed the French defender a red card, before Liverpool quickly exploited their numerical advantage. Dominik Szoboszlai scored from the resulting free-kick and Florian Wirtz added a second in the 13th minute.
Speaking as a Sky Sports pundit, Neville placed much of the blame on De Ligt’s positioning.
“When I saw De Ligt’s name in the team, I have to admit I was really shocked,” Neville said, as reported by the Daily Mail. “I watched him at Como four weeks ago and he was nowhere near the ball. This is just a simple ball over the top.”
Neville said De Ligt’s starting position left Yoro with too much ground to cover, although he also criticised the younger defender for reacting too slowly and failing to deal with the situation properly.
He rejected the suggestion that Isak had deliberately slowed his run to force Yoro into making the foul, arguing that the incident instead exposed United’s poor reading of the danger and their failure to defend long balls effectively.
Harry Maguire was introduced after the dismissal to help reorganise the defence, but Neville felt the change came too late to prevent Liverpool from delivering a major blow to United at the start of Pochettino’s reign.
The former Manchester United defender acknowledged that De Ligt’s long absence through injury might have contributed to his performance. However, he said a major game against Liverpool had exposed weaknesses in the Dutchman’s play. Neville also argued that Yoro should have moved forward to cover his team-mate rather than allowing himself to be drawn into an unfavourable position.
After watching the incident again, Neville said: “It’s astonishing. For Manchester United to have those defenders in their team and still have no chance of keeping a clean sheet is incredible.”
He added that the problem went beyond one mistake, describing United’s organisation as lacking the basic understanding required to defend properly and occupy the correct positions.
Roy Keane also criticised United during half-time, insisting the fundamentals of defending do not change whether a team uses four or five defenders. He said De Ligt’s performance was particularly surprising after his lengthy absence.
Keane added that defenders must always prepare for the worst outcome. While Isak handled the situation well and Yoro had little realistic chance of reaching the ball, he said United’s response showed a lack of danger awareness and poor defensive judgement.
Pochettino’s difficult start therefore involved an early red card, a 2-0 deficit and severe criticism from two former Manchester United captains, with the first half highlighting major defensive problems for the Argentine to address.
