English Premier League
Bayern Munich’s Upamecano gamble pays off as De Ligt faces Manchester United exit

Bayern Munich’s decision to sell Matthijs de Ligt and retain Dayot Upamecano has been vindicated, despite provoking fierce criticism from supporters in 2024. The Dutch defender’s struggles at Manchester United contrast sharply with Upamecano’s growing importance in Germany.
Vincent Kompany played a decisive role in the choice. When he took charge in the summer of 2024, Bayern had five central defenders: Upamecano, Min-jae Kim, De Ligt, Eric Dier and new signing Hiroki Ito. Although reports suggested the club had been prepared to sell Upamecano, Kompany preferred the Frenchman’s pace and physical qualities for his tactical approach.
De Ligt moved to Manchester United in mid-August 2024 for 45m euros, a decision many Bayern fans considered a serious mistake. The centre-back had joined Bayern from Juventus for 67m euros in the summer of 2022, after establishing himself as one of Europe’s leading young defenders with Ajax Amsterdam.
Signed by Julian Nagelsmann at the age of 22, De Ligt enjoyed an impressive first season in Munich. He finished second behind Jamal Musiala in Bayern’s supporters’ vote for the club’s player of the season and remained one of the team’s most dependable defenders the following campaign.
His leadership and commitment made him popular with the fans, particularly as Upamecano had been criticised for costly errors and recurring fitness problems. An online petition titled “Keep De Ligt! We want De Ligt!” collected 71,840 signatures. De Ligt said the support “touches my heart”, but Bayern proceeded with the sale, according to German outlet Spox.
Kompany’s faith in Upamecano gradually appeared justified. He became a regular alongside Kim and later produced strong performances with Jonathan Tah as Bayern began the 2025-26 season. The club subsequently extended Upamecano’s contract until 2030, while he received a signing bonus estimated at about 20m euros at the beginning of 2026.
De Ligt’s injury problems
De Ligt’s time at Manchester United deteriorated after he suffered a back injury in autumn 2025. Ruben Amorim initially described it as “a minor issue”, but repeated setbacks kept the defender out for months. He underwent surgery in May, ending his season and damaging his hopes of representing the Netherlands at the World Cup.
He returned in late October against Como Calcio in the Champions League, a match Manchester United lost 4-1, but made only one further brief appearance in the competition. His last Premier League match came on 30 November 2025, leaving him absent from domestic football for almost a year.
The centre-back has since fallen further down the pecking order. Michael Carrick preferred Harry Maguire and Lisandro Martinez, while Leny Yoro and 20-year-old Ayden Heaven were used when Martinez was suspended. Carrick’s dismissal during the international break and Mauricio Pochettino’s appointment added to the uncertainty.
Despite having a contract until 2029, De Ligt is now a possible departure in January or at the end of the season. Manchester United great Gary Neville said: “De Ligt must leave.” Inter Milan and Turkish club Besiktas are reportedly interested in the 27-year-old, while Upamecano has become one of Bayern’s defensive leaders.
