English Premier League
VAR analysis backs Mbappe penalty decision in Real Madrid’s clash with Celta Vigo

The penalty awarded to Kylian Mbappe during Real Madrid’s meeting with Celta Vigo was the correct decision, according to refereeing analysis account Archivo VAR.
Mbappe was preparing to shoot at the Santiago Bernabeu when Celta Vigo defender Javi Rodriguez held him, affecting the forward’s balance. The referee pointed to the spot and the decision was subsequently confirmed by the video assistant referee.
Archivo VAR reviewed the incident and said Rodriguez’s intervention warranted a penalty, even though the hold was not particularly obvious.
The analysis said Rodriguez grabbed Mbappe by the wrist at the moment the France forward was attempting to strike the ball. That contact disrupted Mbappe’s movement and prevented him from taking the shot normally, meaning the decision to award a penalty was technically correct.
It added that the key consideration was not how clear or forceful the contact appeared, but the effect it had on the player’s movement. Although the hold was neither strong nor exaggerated, its impact on Mbappe’s ability to complete the action was enough to constitute an offence inside the area.
Mbappe took responsibility for the penalty as Real Madrid looked for an equaliser and hoped to avoid a disappointing result against Celta Vigo. However, he sent a poor effort high over the crossbar, with the ball flying into the stands and the opportunity escaping the home side.
The miss was met by whistles from the Santiago Bernabeu crowd. Real Madrid had struggled to impose themselves in attack, while Celta Vigo had made good use of the space available and threatened the hosts’ goal on several occasions.
The home side therefore went into half-time trailing by one goal, with the missed penalty becoming one of the defining moments of the opening half.
Archivo VAR’s assessment
The review focused on the sequence immediately before Mbappe attempted to shoot. Rodriguez’s grip on the forward’s wrist was judged to have altered his balance and directly affected the execution of the effort.
Archivo VAR’s conclusion means the controversy centred on whether the contact was sufficiently significant was resolved in favour of the referee’s decision. The account maintained that a foul does not depend solely on the visibility or intensity of the hold; its influence on the attacking player’s action is also decisive.
